Barrymore thought for a second before yelling out: “Tuna melt!” She shrugged unapologetically as the audience laughed. Colbert pressed further, asking, “Open-faced?” Barrymore was quick to ...

Barrymore quickly declared, “Tuna melt!” without hesitation. Colbert followed up, “Open-faced?” The actress responded, “No. I hate an open-faced sandwich. It’s not a sandwich.” She held up her hands ...

Open-faced Tuna Melts To make the tuna salad, place the tuna in a bowl and flake with a fork. Add the diced celery, onion, apple, mayonnaise, and mustard. Season with salt and pepper. To assemble ...